AZ150 vs Z275 Salt Spray Hours: How to Read Test Data for Coastal Projects

Nov 14, 2026

Leave a message

info-718-404

A buyer sends us two test reports. The first says AZ150, 1,000 hours. The second says Z275, 600 hours. The question that follows is which coil will last longer on a roof three kilometres from the sea. Neither number answers it.

 

Both reports are probably accurate. They were probably not produced in the same way, and that is where the confusion starts. A salt spray data comparison looks simple on paper and is not, which is why we spend more time explaining test reports than explaining coatings.

 

What the test fixes, and what it leaves open

 

Neutral salt spray is a narrow procedure. ISO 9227 and ASTM B117 both specify a 5% sodium chloride solution, a pH between 6.5 and 7.2, a chamber temperature of 35 °C, and a fog collection rate inside a fixed band. Follow either standard and you get the same fog. What the standards leave open is everything the supplier chooses to write down.

 

Coating mass can be verified by stripping the coating, by weigh-strip-weigh, or by X-ray, and some certificates state only the nominal figure with no measured value behind it. Edges can be waxed, taped, or cut and left open. The endpoint can be first white rust, first red rust, or 5% red rust across the assessed area. A report that gives one number and nothing else has recorded a laboratory event. It has not told you how the coil will behave.

 

Reports headed "Galvalume salt spray hours" usually describe 55% aluminium-zinc coated steel. Galvalume is a trade name for a coating family. It is not a coating mass and not a test method, so two suppliers can use the same name and still be testing different products.

 

Why the hours rarely line up

The first reason is that these are two different products, not one product measured twice.

AZ150 carries 150 g/m² of 55% aluminium-zinc across both surfaces, about 75 g/m² per side. Z275 carries 275 g/m² of zinc, about 137 g/m² per side. The alloy is much lighter than zinc, around 4.3 to 5.0 g/cm³ against 7.14, so the physical thicknesses come out close: roughly 15 µm per side for AZ150 and 19 µm for Z275. Alloy and mass change at the same time here. One hour count cannot separate them.

The second reason is the environment inside the cabinet. A neutral salt spray chamber holds the panel wet at 35 °C for weeks on end. Nothing dries. There is no sunlight, no sulphur dioxide, no rain to wash the salt off and no onshore wind to bring more of it back. A coastal facade does all of those things, daily. Panels that rank one way under permanent wetting do not necessarily rank the same way under wet and dry cycles, and adding hours to the test does not change that.

info-1024-779

The third reason is failure sequence. Galvanized steel shows white rust before red rust. An aluminium-zinc surface may go dull grey quite early with no steel corrosion underneath. If the pass criterion is red rust, one product can look better simply because its failure is quieter to see.

 

The fourth reason is arithmetic. No standard converts cabinet hours into years of marine service. ISO 9223 classifies corrosivity from measured chloride deposition, time of wetness and field mass loss. Cabinet hours describe consistency between production lots. Sales sheets that translate one into the other are not supported by anything we have found in the standards.

 

None of this makes the test useless. It makes it a control tool. A mill that reports 900 hours on one lot and 450 on the next has a process problem worth asking about, and that is a fair reason to read the number. It is a poor reason to choose a coating.

 

What coastal exposure data does support

 

Field exposure is slower to produce and harder to argue with. In marine and chloride-heavy atmospheres, 55% aluminium-zinc coatings generally lose less metal on exposed flat surfaces than zinc coatings of similar thickness. The aluminium-rich phase forms an oxide film that holds up reasonably well in chloride, which slows dissolution at the surface. The advantage is real but not unlimited. Once chloride deposition moves into the C5-M or CX classes, the difference narrows and coating continuity matters more than alloy choice.

 

Distance to the coast matters as much as the class on the certificate. A site 100 m from the surf and one three kilometres inland can sit in different ISO 9223 classes with the same rainfall, the same wind rose and the same roof pitch. We have quoted one coating for both before, and we would not do it again.

 

Cut edges behave differently, and this is the part most test reports leave out. Zinc protects bare steel sacrificially over a wider distance. The aluminium-rich alloy protects a shorter margin, so sheared edges, punched holes and deep scratches are its weak points. On a roof or wall, most of the surface is flat sheet and a small fraction is edge. That small fraction is often where the first repair happens.

 

Product type matters as well. On bare coil, salt spray tells you about the metallic coating. On prepainted coil it tells you about the paint: blistering, creep from a scribe, adhesion, read against ISO 12944 or the ASTM D714 and D1654 methods. A painted panel result cannot compare bare AZ150 with bare Z275, though we still see it done in tender documents.

 

Table 1. What each data source is worth

Data source

What it is worth

What to check

Neutral salt spray (ISO 9227, ASTM B117)

Useful, but narrow

Same standard, same endpoint, edge treatment, measured coating mass

Cyclic corrosion test (ASTM G85 Annex A5, ISO 14993, SAE J2334)

More representative

Wet and dry timing, chloride load, cycle count, evaluation method

Coastal field exposure

Highest

Corrosivity class, distance from the surf, panel angle, duration

Six checks we run when a customer sends two reports

 

When both reports land on the same desk, this sequence usually settles the question inside an hour.

 The coating mass certificate, to EN 10346, ASTM A792 or ASTM A653, with the measuring method named.

 Whether the two tests used the same standard. Cyclic against neutral salt spray is not a comparison.

 The endpoint, first red rust or 5% red rust. The difference can run to several hundred hours.

 Whether the panels came from production coil, and whether the edges were sealed.

 The site: ISO 9223 category, prevailing wind relative to the coastline, shelter from terrain, access for maintenance.

 Field or third-party cyclic data, where the order value or the warranty period justifies asking.

 If a supplier cannot answer the first four, the hour count is worth ignoring regardless of how large it is.

 

Choosing between them on a real project

info-1008-1008

The order we use is site first, product form second, detailing third. Once the corrosivity class is fixed, published first-year corrosion rates give a rough life estimate: coating mass per unit area divided by the annual loss rate. It is a planning figure that applies to flat surface rather than to edges or fasteners, but it does compare the two in the same units. The lighter AZ150 coating then recovers part of its mass disadvantage through a lower surface corrosion rate, which is why the two often finish close together on exposed flat areas at the coast while AZ150 stays behind at the cuts.

Detailing decides more than most buyers expect. Sealed edges, compatible fasteners, drainage that works, and no pockets that hold water will add more service life than one step up in coating mass. We would rather quote the coating that suits the site than the one that wins a table.

If your two reports disagree, send them over. We will read the standard, the endpoint, the edge preparation and the coating mass, then tell you which coating matches your corrosivity class and your fixing details. The question that decides the specification is not which number is larger, but which coating suits the exposure your project will actually get.

 

Send Inquiry