
Most coastal projects reach us with the same split. The roof schedule is quoted in AZ150 aluminum-zinc, the purlin schedule in Z275 galvanized, and the two prices sit side by side. The question that follows is always the same. If Z275 carries the heavier coating, why not use it everywhere?
Keep AZ150 on the surfaces that face the weather. Leave the structural decision open until the fabricator confirms how the parts will be cut, drilled and welded. The split is not a compromise. It follows the way each coating fails.
The 150 and the 275 do not measure the same thing
The numbers invite a false comparison. AZ150 carries 150 g/m² across both faces. Z275 carries 275 g/m². Read as bare numbers, zinc looks like nearly double the protection.
It is not. Aluminum-zinc runs at about 3.7 g/cm³ and zinc at about 7.1 g/cm³. Converted to thickness, AZ150 gives roughly 20 micrometers per face and Z275 roughly 19. The lighter coating is the thicker one.
This is also why the two grades are quoted against each other in European and Australasian practice. AZ150, known in the trade as Galvalume, is the aluminum-zinc counterpart of Z275, and the pairing rests on thickness and behavior rather than mass. A comparison that begins with coating weight begins with the wrong unit.
What salt water does to each coating
Both coatings work in two ways. They form a barrier against water and oxygen, and they sacrifice themselves at a break so the steel beside the break stays intact. The coatings differ in how much work each of those mechanisms does.
In a 55% aluminum-zinc coating, aluminum carries the barrier duty. It oxidizes into a thin film that holds under chloride, and the corrosion products stay attached, so the coating keeps its thickness. Zinc behaves differently at the coast. Chloride turns it into soluble salts, rain removes them, leaving fresh zinc exposed for the next cycle. The loss is steady and cumulative.
Exposure work published from the Persian Gulf coast measured the corrosion rate of pure zinc at roughly 1.7 to 2.3 times that of 55% Al-Zn. Salt spray shows a similar spread, with AZ150 reaching 5% red rust between 1,200 and 2,000 hours and Z275 between 400 and 600.
Those are test-site figures, not a service-life promise. A roof in Mombasa and a plant at Jebel Ali do not age at the same rate, and the detail matters as much as the coating.
Why roofing and cladding ends up with AZ150

A profiled sheet presents a large, mostly uninterrupted surface. It is cut only at its ends, and those ends sit inside flashings, gutters and laps. Rain washes the field regularly and removes chloride before it concentrates.
That geometry suits an aluminum-rich coating. The barrier holds across the whole face, and there are few bare edges where the weaker sacrificial performance would show.
The coastal roof failures we see are rarely mid-sheet. They sit at the lap, where two sheets trap water and salt in a gap that never dries, and at the fastener, where a damaged washer lets water sit against the steel. Sealing the ridge end does more for the roof than another 50 g/m² of coating.
Heat load and paint finish support the same choice. An unpainted aluminum-zinc surface reflects much of the solar load, so the sheet runs cooler than galvanized steel under the same sun, and the coating tolerates around 300 °C continuous against about 200 °C for zinc. On the paint line, AZ150 with conversion coating, primer and topcoat is the standard architectural build.
Why the purlins and frames get a different answer
A purlin is not a sheet. It is cut to length, punched at the cleats, drilled for bolts, welded at the bracket, then dragged across a site. Every one of those steps leaves bare steel, and bare steel is where the two coatings part company.
Zinc protects an exposed edge by sacrificing itself, and the protection reaches several millimeters into the break. The zinc-rich phase in aluminum-zinc does the same work but holds a smaller share of the coating, so the protected band is narrower, roughly one to two millimeters. A couple of cut ends is a detail. Fifty punched holes and a welded bracket is a maintenance schedule.
Welding is the harder constraint. Neither coating is designed to be welded through, and aluminum-zinc punishes the shortcut. Aluminum oxide resists fusion, inclusions end up in the weld metal, and the coating is damaged beyond the visible heat tint. The method is to strip the weld zone, weld with a matching filler, and rebuild the area with a zinc-rich compound. Galvanized steel follows the same steps with less difficulty, using materials an erector already carries.
Forming is a separate issue. Aluminum-zinc is harder and less ductile at tight radii and can crack along a sharp fold. Roll-formed profiles are fine; hand-folded details and tight hems are not. Zinc is softer, marks in transport, and tolerates rough site cutting with fewer consequences.
Repair matters too. A damaged galvanized surface can be restored with a zinc-rich cold galvanizing compound to ASTM A780, and the repair continues the electrochemical protection. On aluminum-zinc, a repair is a patch. It acts as a barrier but does not shield the steel beside it the way the original coating did.
One case reverses the argument. Where a member is fully painted and maintained, the paint carries the duty and the coating becomes the backup. AZ150 then serves structural parts, provided cut edges are sealed and welds repaired to a written procedure. Several coastal warehouses are built that way.
Where a frame carries a lot of welding, the cleaner route is uncoated steel galvanized after fabrication to EN ISO 1461. That removes the conflict between the coating and the weld instead of managing it on site.
The decision, part by part
Table 1. Coating selection by part
|
Part |
Coating |
Reason it fits |
|
Roof cladding |
AZ150 |
Large rain-washed face, few bare edges, barrier does the work |
|
Wall cladding |
AZ150 |
Same exposure pattern, same edge logic |
|
Purlins and framing |
Depends on fabrication |
Cut edges, holes and welds decide the outcome |
|
Members under a maintained paint system |
Either |
Paint carries the duty, coating is the backup |
|
Members in contact with concrete or mortar |
Z275 |
Alkaline pore water attacks aluminum |
|
Heavily welded frames |
Z275, or uncoated then hot-dip galvanized |
Strip and repair procedures are simpler |
Four questions settle most cases. Is the part a continuous sheet, or an assembly of cut, drilled and welded pieces? Which ISO 9223 category applies, and how much chloride does the site carry? How many welds are there, and can the coating be repaired at each? Are cut edges sealed, lapped into a flashing, or left bare?
Writing the coating into the specification
Most substitution problems begin with a loose specification. "Aluminum-zinc coated" and "galvanized" are descriptions rather than grades, and more than one product satisfies either phrase.
Write the designation and the mass together. For cladding, DX51D+AZ150 to EN 10346 with a minimum of 150 g/m² over both faces, or AZ150 to AS/NZS 1397 where that standard governs. For structure, S350GD+Z275 to EN 10346 with 275 g/m² total, or the ASTM A653 G90 equivalent. Ask for the coating mass on the inspection certificate to EN 10204 3.1. A grade alone says nothing about the surface facing the weather.
Put two more items in the same clause: how cut edges are to be treated, and which fastener and washer are approved for the profile. Both decide whether the coating is still doing its job in year eight.
If a supplier offers AZ150 in place of Z275 on the structural schedule, or the reverse, ask for the fabrication route before accepting. The coatings are not interchangeable by mass, and on a welded or heavily punched member they are not interchangeable by application.
If you are preparing a coastal tender, send the cladding schedule, the corrosivity category and the way the parts will be cut and joined. We will quote the coating that fits each item, and say where the detail rather than the grade is likely to limit service life.