Most enquiries that reach our desk name one number and stop there. Z275, occasionally AZ150, this thickness, this tonnage, best price. Coating mass is the line buyers compare in a tender, so it becomes the line everyone argues about. It tells you how much metal sits on the steel, not how long the steel will last where the building stands. Those are different questions, and in many quotations they never meet.
What usually settles the outcome is the site's corrosivity category under ISO 9223. Before we price a coastal roof we ask three things: how far the steel sits from salt water, whether the part will be painted, and what service life the owner is promising. In practice the galvanized vs Galvalume comparison is rarely settled by mass. Those three answers move our recommendation further than a change of grade.
How each coating protects the steel
Hot-dip galvanized coil works by sacrifice. Zinc is less noble than steel, so when the coating is cut, the zinc beside the damage corrodes first and keeps the steel cathodic. In open air a zinc surface also grows a thin patina of basic zinc carbonate, which slows the attack. The protection is finite. It ends when that zinc is consumed, and the sacrificial reach along a cut edge is only a few millimetres.
Galvalume works on a different principle. The coating is 55% aluminium, 43.4% zinc and 1.6% silicon, freezing into aluminium-rich dendrites with a zinc-rich network between them. The protecting film is aluminium oxide: thin, dense, slow to dissolve in near-neutral conditions, and not consumed the way zinc is. The zinc network still acts at cut edges, so this is not a pure barrier coating. The silicon keeps the alloy layer at the interface thin, which stops the coating cracking during roll-forming.

AZ150 vs Z275: the numbers do not compare
Z275 carries 275 g/m² of zinc over both surfaces, roughly 137 g/m² per side. AZ150 carries 150 g/m² of alloy, roughly 75 g/m² per side. On coating mass the aluminium-zinc coil looks like a downgrade of nearly half, and buyers reject it on that reading. Thickness is fairer. Zinc runs at 7.14 g/cm³ and the alloy near 4.9, so Z275 builds about 19 µm per side and AZ150 about 15. The gap is a quarter, not a half.
What decides it is coating loss per year on site. ISO 9224 gives indicative zinc rates of 0.1 to 0.7 µm a year in C2, 0.7 to 2.0 in C3, 2 to 4 in C4 and 4 to 8 in C5. The alloy producers publish service-life data putting aluminium-zinc at about half that rate in mixed industrial and marine exposure. Run those figures against 19 and 15 µm and the downgrade disappears. Standards differ too: Z275 sits under ASTM A653 or EN 10346, AZ150 under ASTM A792 or EN 10346. Read the certificate, not the abbreviation.
C2 and C3: we still specify zinc
For most inland projects we quote, zinc is the right answer. C2 covers dry, low-pollution sites; C3 covers urban and light industrial locations, plus coastal sites with little salinity. At 0.1 to 2 µm a year a Z275 panel in C3 has twenty years or more of coating left before steel is exposed. Over a 20 to 25 year design life the AZ150 premium rarely shows up in a number the owner can test.
We still recommend zinc when the site is mild, the part touches fresh concrete or alkaline soil, the coil gets painted anyway, or the tender turns on price per tonne. Aluminium-zinc is not wrong there; it is more durability than the project will inspect.
C4: where the recommendation flips
C4 changes our answer. It covers coastal sites with moderate salinity, industrial areas with real sulphur dioxide, and anywhere roads are salted in winter. Zinc loss rises to 2 to 4 µm a year, which puts first red rust on a bare Z275 panel between eight and twelve years. That is not a theoretical figure. It is the pattern behind most coating complaints we are asked to look at.
In C4 the aluminium-zinc coating becomes the default substrate for unpainted roofing, cladding and deck. The oxide film holds across the near-neutral pH range and re-forms after damage, and the loss rate is about half. Two conditions still work against it: direct contact with fresh concrete or alkaline material, and a cavity that stays wet and never dries.
C5: a system question, not a coating question
In C5-I and C5-M the arithmetic stops being kind. At 4 to 8 µm a year, 19 µm of zinc is gone in three to five years, and 15 µm of alloy is not far behind. Bare metal has no business being specified here, whatever name is printed on the coil. Galvalume fails where you cannot see it: slit edges, fastener holes, the underside of laps, the back of a profile.
What works is a duplex system: an organic coil coating over AZ150, or AZ185 and AZ200 where exposure is heavy, with a specified primer, a dry film thickness the applicator can hold, and edge and back-side protection. The paint takes the atmosphere; the metallic layer takes the cut. On milder C5 industrial sites Z350 or Z450 under paint is still defensible, though prepaint work shows underfilm corrosion creeping further from a scribe on zinc than on aluminium-zinc. Either way, put washing and inspection into the maintenance plan. Nothing survives C5 unattended.
The short version, for a meeting
If you need the argument on one page, this is how we compress it. Treat the table as a first filter, then check the site against measured chloride and sulphur dioxide deposition. A boundary site usually behaves one category worse than the map suggests. The duplex column is a cost line, not an upsell.

Table 1. Coating choice by ISO 9223 corrosivity category
|
Category |
Choose zinc (Z) when |
Choose aluminium-zinc (AZ) when |
Duplex system |
|
C1 |
Dry interior, sheltered storage, no condensation |
Rarely justified |
Not required |
|
C2–C3 |
Price-led tender, 20–25 year life, alkaline contact, later painting |
Longer unpainted life is required |
Optional, for appearance |
|
C4 |
Sheltered or medium-duty exposure, alkaline contact |
Default for bare roofing, cladding and deck |
Recommended for visible work |
|
C5-I / C5-M |
Not recommended as a bare coating |
AZ150 or AZ185 substrate under paint only |
Mandatory |
What to send us, and what comes back
We supply both coatings, so this is not an argument we win by pushing one. Send the site location and distance from the coast, the ISO 9223 category or measured deposition rates, the service life the owner is promising, whether the part will be painted, and how you plan to form and cut the coil. Long slit edges and exposed back sides change our answer more often than the coating class does. We come back with a coating class, the standard it is released against, and the coating mass on the mill certificate, checked by weigh-strip-weigh.
One boundary worth stating. We supply coil. We do not design your purlins, sign your structural calculations or model your cavity ventilation; that belongs to your engineer. What we can tell you is what the coating will do in the environment you describe, and where it stops doing it.
Technical sales, Shandong Pinjie New Material Co., Ltd.
If you are weighing the two for a live project, our coating classes, substrate grades and thickness ranges sit on the product pages: galvanized steel coil at sino-galvanized.com/galvanized-steel-coil and galvalume steel coil at sino-galvanized.com/galvalume-steel-coil. If you would rather settle it against a drawing, send the drawing through sino-galvanized.com/inquiry and we will answer with the coating, not the catalogue.