Why Chromium-Free Galvalume Coil Costs More Than Chromated

Nov 18, 2026

Leave a message

 

You have two offers for the same coil. Same substrate, same coating weight, same dimensions. The only line that differs is the surface treatment, and the chromium-free one is dearer. Before the purchase order goes out, someone asks you to justify it.

 

We answer that question often, and the short version is this: chromium-free passivation is not a premium version of the same process. It is a different process, with a different chemistry, a narrower operating window and a heavier paperwork load. Some of that cost belongs in your project. Some of it does not.

 

We run both treatments and quote both, so what follows comes from our own costing, not from a brochure.

 

info-600-338

 

Why the chromium-free price difference exists

 

Passivation is the last wet step before the coil is wound. A thin conversion film, measured in tens of milligrams per square metre, goes onto the freshly cooled 55% aluminium-zinc surface. Three things depend on it. The coil has to come out of the container without white rust. The surface has to accept paint without a pretreatment failure. And the wraps have to stay free of each other under stack weight.

 

Chromated systems form that film by reaction between chromium compounds and the alloy surface. The reaction is quick, and it is forgiving. Shift the pH a little, stretch the dwell time, and the film still forms. Chromium-free systems build the film differently, from titanium or zirconium complexes, silane, or a water-borne resin. They need hydrolysis and condensation first, then heat to cure. Forgiving is not the word for them.

info-490-490
info-1080-1080

The chemical drum is not the big number

 

Chromated chemistry is a commodity. Several suppliers, steady consumption, and decades of line experience behind the dosing schedule. Chromium-free chemistry is specialty chemistry: fewer suppliers, smaller production runs, a higher price per kilogram, and a bath that ages faster. Several systems also call for demineralised water and finer filtration, which adds a utility bill and one more thing to maintain.

 

On our own cost sheet, the chemical is not the largest line. It is simply the line that moved. The larger numbers sit further down the process.

 

The line is where it gets expensive

 

A chromium-free bath gives you less room. Solids, pH, temperature, dwell and squeeze-roll pressure all want tighter control, and the film needs a higher peak metal temperature at the drier to cure. On a line whose speed is already set by its cooling section, that temperature can decide whether you run at rate or below it. Slower line, same labour, same overheads, higher cost per tonne.

 

Then there is what a trace of chromium does. Carry a little chromated drag-out into a chromium-free bath and the finished coil can fail a verification test. So the tanks, the recirculation loop and the rollers stay separate, and a changeover means cleaning, not just switching a pump.

 

Film weight has a narrower target as well. Too light and the stack shows white rust by the time it reaches your customer. Too heavy and the wraps block, welding gets awkward, paint adhesion can drift. You end up inspecting more often and rejecting more at start-up.

 

The paperwork is part of the product

 

A chromium-free claim has to be provable, and proving it is work. Spot testing for hexavalent chromium on the coating, by the method described in IEC 62321-7-1, along with quantitative checks after alkaline digestion, are routine on this route. Regulated buyers want a declaration of conformity, a report for each lot, retention samples and an entry in their supplier portal. For an appliance programme, a coil without the report is not a coil.

 

Corrosion qualification sits on top of that. Neutral salt spray to ASTM B117, cyclic testing to ASTM G85, and stacked-coil tests in a humid room. Each of them consumes coil and laboratory time before a single tonne is sold. You will not see any of it on the surface. It is in the price.

 

Volume, and why the gap has not closed

 

Chromated passivation still carries most of the tonnage in most markets, and that tonnage pays for competitive chemical pricing, experienced operators and settled procedures. Chromium-free is growing, mostly because specifications and regulations push it, but the base is smaller: smaller batches, more grade changes, less accumulated line time, fewer qualified chemical suppliers. There are more buyers than before, and still not the volume that pulls unit cost down.

 

Table 1. Where the two treatments part company on cost

Cost factor

Chromated

Chromium-free

Where it shows up

Passivation chemistry

Commodity, several suppliers, steady consumption

Specialty, fewer suppliers, shorter bath life

Added to conversion cost

Line control

Wide window, forgives drift

Tight window, higher cure temperature, separate tanks

Slower running, more off-spec at start-up

Testing and documents

Routine declaration

Spot test per lot, third-party reports, portal entries

Chargeable service work

Qualification

Existing test data

Salt spray, cyclic and stack tests before launch

One-off, recovered over volume

Volume

Large installed base

Smaller base, more grade changes

Keeps the gap open

 

When the higher price is the cheaper decision

 

Three situations come up again and again in our order book.

 

The first is regulation. Directive 2011/65/EU restricts hexavalent chromium in electrical and electronic equipment, and REACH obligations sit alongside it. If the coil ends up in equipment sold into the European Union, the premium is the entry ticket to that market. There is no cheaper compliant route.

 

The second is a specification you did not write. Appliance makers, automotive tiers and some architectural tenders put chromium-free in the document. Then the question is not whether to pay it. It is whether your supplier can prove it, lot by lot, when the auditor asks.

 

The third is distance. A container that crosses an ocean for six weeks and then sits in a yard through a humid month will find every weakness in a passivation film. If one rejected container costs more than the premium on ten, the decision has already been made for you.

 

When chromated still earns its place

 

There are projects where the extra money buys nothing you need. Domestic sales with no chromium restriction. Short storage in a dry yard. A tender that asks only for a passivated surface. And any coil that will be alkaline-cleaned and pretreated before painting, because that pretreatment strips the film you paid for.

 

One distinction is worth carrying into the meeting. Chromium-free is not the same claim as hexavalent-chromium-free. RoHS targets hexavalent chromium, and a trivalent system sits outside that restriction. Many chromated coils on the market already use trivalent chemistry, because Cr(VI) has been under pressure for years. Ask what your offer actually contains before you treat chromated as non-compliant by default. The answer sometimes closes the price gap on its own.

 

What we will not put in a quotation

 

We will not give you a standard percentage for the difference, because there is no such number. It moves with the chemical system, the line, the batch size, the film weight and the documents your customer wants. A figure invented for a web page would be worse than no figure at all.

 

What we will do is itemise. Passivation type, target film weight, the test reports that travel with each lot, and what the treatment costs against a chromated alternative on the same substrate. If two offers are in front of you and only the treatment differs, that breakdown is the only honest way to compare them.

 

Four questions before you accept the difference

 

These are the ones we ask when a buyer sends us two competing offers.

 

 Does the document ban chromium, or only hexavalent chromium? The two answers lead to different prices.

 Will anyone test the coil after it leaves you? If an OEM runs spot tests on incoming material, the report matters as much as the film.

 How long is the coil in transit and in storage, and how humid is the yard it sits in?

 Does your paint line remove the passivation anyway?

 

Two or more answers pointing to compliance, testing or long exposure, and the premium is usually recoverable. If none of them does, ask the supplier to separate chemistry from yield from paperwork. A supplier who cannot is not really quoting the difference.

 

Comparing the two offers on the same basis

 

Both treatments run on our lines, and we quote whichever the specification calls for. Every offer states the passivation type, the target film weight and the documents supplied with each lot, so the two numbers can be read side by side. Surface treatment options, coating weights and coil sizes are listed on our galvalume steel coil page. Send us the specification and the destination port, and we will tell you which treatment the route actually needs.

 

Chromium-free coil is dearer for reasons that can be listed. Whether those reasons apply to your order is a separate question, and it is the one worth answering before you sign.

 

Send Inquiry